Star Reviews

Monday, October 26, 2026

 

I’ve been reading The Last Year of the War by Susan Meissner, and I recommend the book to anyone interested in historical fiction. The story is told by a German American girl whose family was confined at the Crystal City internment camp during World War II and then “repatriated” to Germany while the war was still going on.  A significant part of the story involves her friendship with a Japanese American girl who she met at Crystal City.

My first middle-grade historical novel, Desert Jewels, is about a Japanese American girl who was living in California when the Japanese bombed Pearl Harbor and was subsequently sent to the Topaz internment camp in Utah. So I have always been interested in the internment camps. Since half of my blood traces back to Germany, that connection interested me, too.

The Last Year of the War is heavy on narrative, which is not my favorite writing style, but it works here. I also found one or two minor factual errors about the Japanese “removal,” but the author admits that she has changed a few non-essential facts for the sake of the story. Other than that, her research matches my own for Desert Jewels.

When I heard about The Last Year of the War, I checked it out on Amazon. I started with the “look inside” feature and moved on to the reviews.

As I’ve mentioned before on this blog, I don’t generally bother with four- or five-star reviews. Reading tastes differ, and I’ve been bored by many books that are heavy on good reviews. No, I head straight for the one- and two-star reviews. Among those, I discount the ones that show a general dislike for the author’s style since, as I said, reading tastes differ. Instead, I look to see if any of the reviews point out excessive swearing or explicit sex or—worst of all—bad research.

As you can see from the graphic at the top of this post, there were no one-star reviews, so I moved on to the two-star reviews. Most of them said more about the reviewers than they did about the book, and they made me angry. Or, more accurately, they made me sad that the reviewers lacked understanding of human nature and the value of recognizing the darker days of America’s history.

Those will be the subjects of subsequent blog posts, so stay tuned.


No comments:

Post a Comment