I belonged to six Presbyterian
churches as I grew up, but I had only one minister. And Daddy was a strong
Christian whose sermons were firmly grounded in the Bible.
When I went to college, I
visited several churches and ended up attending Third Reformed (in Holland,
Michigan). Like the churches from my childhood, Third’s teaching was rooted in
solid theology.
So when I moved to
Chicago for graduate school, I expected to find more of the same.
Unfortunately, not all churches and ministers are alike, even within the same
denomination.
I visited two or three
churches in Chicago looking for a place to belong. It was probably my second
time at Fourth Presbyterian Church when I heard an announcement that they were
still looking for Sunday School teachers. Although I hadn’t heard the senior minister
preach yet, it was a Presbyterian church, so how could I go wrong? That’s what
I thought at the time, anyway.
I’m not sure how long it
was before I began having doubts. I remember taking an evening class from the
senior minister and disagreeing with his Biblical analysis. The incident that
stands out most was the day he said sins were always black and white, never
gray. So I asked about 1 Corinthians 8, which talks about food offered to
idols. According to Paul (as I read the passage), mature Christians who
understand that the meat is just meat don’t sin when they eat it privately or
with other equally mature Christians, but those who think that eating food
offered to idols is a sin actually sin when they do so. I was willing to be
persuaded that I had misinterpreted either the passage or the senior minister’s
words. But he gave me a brusque “it doesn’t mean that” and moved on without
explaining why not. If it was simply a matter of not liking his personality,
however, I would have swallowed my pride and lived with it. But I had also
heard several of his sermons by then, and they always made me uneasy.
The turning point came on
Easter Sunday, when I sat through his entire sermon and didn’t hear him mention
Jesus once. The next week I began visiting other churches and found one that
was rooted in solid theology, although I didn’t join until I had attended long
enough to be sure of that. Then I got married and joined my current church,
which is also Biblically grounded.
Fast forward 45 years.
I went to a writers’
conference in Chicago over the weekend. I couldn’t attend services at my own
church without missing some of the sessions. The conference was just down the
block from Fourth Presbyterian, however, and its 8:00 a.m. service worked with
the conference schedule. So although I had some trepidation, I went. The sermon
was short on doctrine, but at least it included references to Jesus. The liturgy
had a bigger impact, and it was uplifting. Fourth Presbyterian may still not be
a church I want to belong to, but it sufficed for that one visit.
This isn’t a
denominational issue. I’ve been to other Presbyterian churches in the last 45
years—either on vacation or while visiting family—and come away feeling
satisfied. And every denomination has its renegades. In the end, it comes down
to the individual churches and their pastors and whether they espouse solid
Biblical teaching.
I believe in working from
within when there are political or personal differences in a congregation. But
if the teaching found there doesn’t feed my faith, I need to find a church that
does.
I’m just glad I learned
that lesson 45 years ago.